Why there are fears that Ethiopia could break up - The Habesha: Latest Ethiopian News and Point of View 24/7

Why there are fears that Ethiopia could break up

13 mins read
7

By Desta Gebremedhin

The feud between Ethiopian Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed and the ruling party in the strategically important Tigray region is escalating, raising fears of military confrontation and the break-up of Africa’s second most-populous nation.
The tensions revolve around the regional government’s decision to press ahead with organising its own election for the Tigray parliament on Wednesday, in an unprecedented act of defiance against the federal government.
This is the latest sign that Mr Abiy is struggling to retain his reputation as a peace-broker – about a year after he won the Nobel Peace Prize for ending a border war with Eritrea and for his efforts to democratise Ethiopia.
About 9,000 people have been arrested in Ethiopia in the deadly clashes which followed the killing of singer Hachalu Hundessa in June, human rights activists say, leading to concerns that there could be a return to the authoritarian rule that the prime minister had promised to end when he took office in 2018.

What is the cause of tensions?

The ruling party in the region, the Tigray People’s Liberation Front (TPLF), sent political shockwaves across Ethiopia, when it announced that elections for a regional parliament would take place despite the federal government and electoral board announcing the postponement of all elections.
Since the end of Marxist rule in 1991 and up until recently, the TPLF had been in a ruling coalition of ethnically based parties, each in control of their own region in a federal system. So its disagreement with Mr Abiy is a deep fracture at the very core of power in the country.
A resident of Mekelle region rides a horse painted in the colours of the Tigray regional flag as they attend celebrations marking the 45th anniversary of the launching of the "Armed Struggle of the Peoples of Tigray", on February 19, 2020, in MekelleIMAGE COPYRIGHTGETTY IMAGES
image captionThe TPLF lost its clout in the federal government after Abiy Ahmed took office
The TPLF argued – like opposition groups – that Mr Abiy’s mandate should end this month as the parliamentary terms comes to an end, and the postponement of elections that were supposed to have happened in August, was in breach of the constitution and raised the prospect of Mr Abiy becoming an “illegitimate” ruler.
Mr Abiy’s allies say the electoral commission postponed the election because of the outbreak of coronavirus, and not because the prime minister wants to cling to power, as opposition parties argue.
They say that he remains a legitimate ruler, as the federal parliament has extended his term for a further 12 months, by when the threat posed by the pandemic would hopefully recede and elections would be held.

So what is the significance of the TPLF’s decision?

It has raised concern that the TPLF could be laying the groundwork for the creation of a breakaway state, with a parliament and government taking office without the blessing of the federal government.
The TPLF maintains that it is committed to keeping the region within Ethiopia, but it will defend “self-rule” and oppose what it calls Mr Abiy’s attempt build a strong “unitary” state.
“We will never back down for anyone who is intending to suppress our hard-won right to self-determination and self-rule,” the region’s leader, Debretsion Gebremichael, said last month.
Members of the special forces paraded in major cities of the region including the capital, Mekelle.
image captionThe Tigray government has vowed to defend the territory under its control
His statement came a few days after regional security forces – armed with AK-47 rifles and RPG rocket launchers – marched in major cities in Tigray, in a display of military might that intensified worries about armed confrontation.
“We are ready to pay the necessary price for our peace,” the region’s security office wrote on Facebook on the day of the parade.

What has been Mr Abiy’s government’s response?

It has declared the Tigray elections illegal, saying that only the national electoral board has the power to organise polls.
Election preparations
image captionThe regional election will be the first one held without the federal government’s approval
However, Mr Abiy has ruled out sending federal troops into the region to stop the election, saying it would be “madness” to do so.
“The federal government has no intention and interest to attack its own people,” he said on 25 July.
But pro-Abiy hardliners, including former army General Kassaye Chemeda, have called for military intervention in Tigray.
“The government should plan well, and they should be attacked,” he said in an interview with the government-affiliated Walta TV.
The International Crisis Group (ICG) think-tank says that some federal officials have raised the possibility of retaliating by taking “punitive” action against the Tigray government – for instance, by withholding financial grants, which amount to half the region’s budget.
Responding to a call by the upper house of the federal government to meet on Saturday to discuss Tigray’s election, the regional government warned that any decision to stop or disrupt the regional election is “tantamount to declaration of war”.
Furthermore, Tigrayan members of the upper house said they would boycott the meeting.

Why have relations soured so much?

The TPLF – which was extremely influential in the federal government since Marxist rule ended in 1991, with its leader, Meles Zenawi, serving as prime minister from 1995 to 2012 – has keenly felt the loss of power under Mr Abiy.
It saw the prime minister’s widely welcomed campaign to end human rights abuses and corruption as a victimisation of TPLF members, especially after senior military and security officers were either purged or arrested soon after Mr Abiy took office in 2018 following mass protests against the former regime.
A picture taken on July 6, 2019, shows a view of Mekelle, the capital of Tigray Region, Ethiopia.IMAGE COPYRIGHTGETTY IMAGES
image captionFormer Prime Minister Meles Zenawi had strong support in Mekelle, the capital of Tigray.
Ex-spy chef Getachew Assefa managed to evade arrest after reportedly fleeing to Tigray.
The TPLF’s influence at the centre weakened even further after Mr Abiy launched the Prosperity Party (PP) – a merger of ethnically-based parties that used to form the ruling coalition.
The TPLF refused to join the PP, leaving it without any influence in the federal government for the first time since Marxist rule ended. Mr Abiy sacked some of its members from the cabinet, while others resigned.
As a result, the TPLF has increasingly retreated to its regional headquarters, Mekelle, raising concerns that its ties with the rest of Ethiopia were loosening.
The federal government crackdown following Hachalu’s killing has also fuelled what some analysts call a siege mentality within the TPLF.
Security forces raided and closed the office of a TPLF-affiliated television station, Dimtsi Woyane, in the capital. They also shut the Oromo Media Network’s television station, which is linked to detained opposition politician Jawar Mohammed.
Federal and PP officials accused the TPLF of involvement in Hachalu’s murder, and of “working to destabilise the country”.
The TPLF responded by saying that the party was being scapegoated for Mr Abiy’s “incompetent rule” and the “mess created by his administration”.

How serious is the threat of secession?

The TPLF played a pivotal role in the overthrow of the Marxist regime in 1991, and the drafting of the constitution that gives ethnic groups the right to self-determination and their own state.
Although the party has never expressed any desire for Tigray to secede, it has always said this right should be respected.
An attendee holds a rifle as people dance during the Tigray People's Liberation Front (TPLF) First Emergency General Congress in Mekelle, Ethiopia, on January 4, 2020IMAGE COPYRIGHTGETTY IMAGES
image captionTPLF members showed their loyalty to the party at its congress in January
Furthermore, a new opposition party, the Tigray Independence Party (TIP), has emerged to contest the regional election. It describes Ethiopia as an “empire”, and says its prime mission is to secure Tigray’s independence.
Some academics in Tigray are also entertaining the idea of secession. So for the first time since 1991, the topic is on the agenda of mainstream politics in Tigray.
Two other Tigray nationalist parties contesting the poll, Salsay Woyane Tigrai and Baytona, say they want the region to have more autonomy to secure its territorial integrity, promote its language, and preserve its heritage.
Map
The TPLF currently controls all the seats in the regional parliament, and the election will be carefully watched to see if the more nationalist and pro-secession parties win some seats to pursue their agenda further.
As for Mr Abiy, he has repeatedly said that Ethiopia will “never” disintegrate, indicating that he is confident that he can hold the nation together, despite the ethnic, religious and political violence that has hit different parts of the country, leaving about two million people homeless since he took office.
The TPLF says the displaced include about 120,000 Tigrayans, who constitute, according to the 2007 census, around 6% of the population.

What about mediation efforts?

On 16 August, more than 50 religious leaders, elders and prominent personalities travelled from the federal capital, Addis Ababa, to Mekelle city in an attempt to ease tensions. The fruit of their efforts are yet to be seen.
The ICG think-tank said “weightier” mediators may be needed.
“Prominent African statesmen with strong ties to both the TPLF and Abiy could play this role,” it added.
Other analysts say this is vital as the success of Ethiopia’s peace initiative with Eritrea hinges on stability in Tigray.
Chairman of the Tigray People's Liberation Front (TPLF) Debretsion Gebremichael delivers a speech during the TPLF First Emergency General Congress in Mekelle, Ethiopia, on January 4, 2020IMAGE COPYRIGHTGETTY IMAGES
image captionTPLF leader Debretsion Gebremichael has a strained relationship with the prime minister
The region borders Eritrea, and was at the centre of the 1998 war between the two nations.
Tens of thousands were killed in the conflict after Eritrea launched an offensive to gain control of the town of Badme from Ethiopia’s Tigray region.
Mr Abiy signed a deal in 2018 with Eritrea’s President Isaias Afwerki to end the “state of war”, resulting in border crossings between the two countries reopening.
However, the border crossings are once again shut. The reasons are unclear, but the Ethiopian government at one point said that the two countries were working to establish proper customs posts.
Nor has the status of Badme been resolved. Eritrea wants Ethiopia to abide by a UN-backed border commission ruling to hand over the town. But this cannot be achieved without the cooperation of the government in Tigray, as it administers the area.
So, the Nobel laureate may find that to achieve lasting peace with Eritrea, he will first need to resolve his differences with the TPLF.

BBC

7 Comments

  1. Notwithstanding Covid the reality is that the political environment in the country is not conducive for holding free & fair elections. If elections were held you can bet your bottom dollar that opportunists will use it to sew discord; perhaps on greater scale than what we’ve seen to date.

    If TPLF had an iota of concern for the country it would be moderating its position as elections are not a panacea. Since when has TPLF been a champion of referendum in the first place?

    Unfortunately, the aging TPLF tribalist leadership doesn’t get it, stuck in their archaic ways as a one trick Marxist pony. To them anything and everything is a nail that must be dealt with a hammer. There is a long list of those like TLF, EDU, EPRP, ELF, OLF, EPLF, ONLF, Kinijit to name a few.

    TPLF has been defiling this constitution of its making since the get go in 1994. If it fails to respect the ruling of the HoF and goes ahead with the elections, it’s not like we’re breaking precedent here. For the rest of us the sooner this group goes the way of the dodo bird the better. Go get’em Fenkel. We support you 100%.

  2. Subject: “Why there are fears that Ethiopia could break up” by Desta Gebremedhin, ZeHabesha
    September 6, 2020

    Quick and Naive Answer:
    The Constitution of the Country, which is more than about thirty-years old, [I stand to be corrected] is NOT RESPECTED by LEADERS but only by ordinary people. The ORDINARY PEOPLE of ETHIOPIA would like to have normal, peaceful , productive LIFE like any other human being around the Globe. There is no a shred of a doubt about it. It is the individual leaders who are constantly spoiling the “SOUP”. And they will NOT rest until ETHIOPIA is shredded into pieces. That is their vision and their happiness — strange as it may seem. If in doubt, Dear Ordinary Readers, go back to history and tune your minds to the atrocities of individuals: absolute>> cruel >> dictators around the Globe. Who paid the price for all their madness? OF course, the ORDINARY PEOPLE who are always sacrificial lambs for a few lunatic individuals. CHECK HISTORY and BE HONEST to YOURSELF, by YOURSELF. After all, it is YOUR LIFE at stake!!!!! THE END

  3. Do you call this journalistic reporting? All the photos in the article are from Tigray only and not of the ordinary people but mostly of the militia of that region. They are shown toting the temples of the commie despots, guns, guns and guns. Even the know better elderly are shown brandishing tools of murder and destruction, guns!!! Guns here, guns over there and guns everywhere!!! O BBC!!!! You are losing respect day by day. Chairman Debre is using the BBC to scare the heck out of more than 100 million peace mongering people. What a shame!!!

  4. Good riddance and መንገዱን ጨርቅ ያርግላችሁ: The sooner the better. The demographics projection should have been a sobering thought to the people of Tigrai: the current population of the
    Tigrai region is 4.96 million and the population of Ethiopia proper is 115 million. Based on current Ethiopian population growth rate, in a mere 30 years from now the population of Ethiopia is projected to be 240-250 million. Assuming similar growth rate for Tigrai, its population will be around 10 million mark. With GERD completed and the rapid industrialisation that follows, the old country will be calling the shots in the entire region. I feel sorry for the poor people of Tigrai for it is not their choice but that of the ageing curse of Tigrai the TPLF.

  5. Laughable reporting. Full of TPLF propaganda and grandstanding.

    Break up of the country??? Nothing more than a self-fulfilling prophecy! But no one can stop you from dreaming!

    A feud between Abiy and TPLF leadership?? No, No. It is between the Federal Govt and TPLF.

    Admit it, Desta Gebremedhin. This piece is sent to you by Getachew Reda (may be you translated / edited part of it in BBCian style).

  6. ኣይተ/ወይዘሮ “መንገዱን ጨርቅ ያርግላችሁ”፣

    Population of Tigray already in the year of 2020 (በፈረንጅ አቆጣጠር) 10.000.000 (አስር ሚልዮን)
    ደግሞም ምድሪቱ የምትገመግመው quantity ብላ ብቻ ሳይሆን quality የሚለውን ጉዳይንም ግምት ውስጥ ታስገበዋለችና፣ አንቺ/አንተም ከምድሪቱ አገማገሞች ጋራ መግባባት ይኖርብሃል/ይኖርብሻል፣ ከተወሰነ ቀናት በኋላ ደግሞ የነመለሱ the ድንክ …….. ከናቱ ጋራ ሲዋሃድ የሚከተል ሁናቴ የሚመጣ መሆኑን መገንዘብ ……………..!! እንደናንተ አይነቱ ካለፈ በኋላ ደግሞ ይሄ የአቆጣጠር መልክ ዋጋ አይኖረውም፣ ምክኒያቱም ሃይማኖታችን unity in diversity ብቻ ይሆናልና!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.